Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Costello's Market
Welcome to Costello's Market, a culinary treasure nestled at 99 Maple St, Middlebury, VT. This charming eatery is more than just a market; it's a delightful experience that caters to all your foodie desires. With a reputation built on fresh ingredients and friendly service, Costello's invites you to discover the flavors that have customers raving.
As you step inside, you're greeted by the warmth of a family-run establishment. Customers like Nichole Woods describe it as an "amazing hidden gem," showcasing an array of dishes that highlight the freshest fish and delectable salads. From her experience, it's hard not to be tempted to indulge in their broccoli salad—something she wished she ordered in a larger size!
Bite into a shrimp po boy that Matthew Harvey proclaimed 'absolutely phenomenal.' The shrimp is warm and lightly breaded, perfectly balanced by a crunchy baguette, delivering a pleasing texture alongside fresh veggies and a tangy dressing. This is just a glimpse into the flavor-packed offerings that await you.
Families are guaranteed a satisfying meal at Costello's, as demonstrated by Alexandra Neumann. She noted the quick service for her entire family, which included a variety of sandwiches and the highly praised fish and chips. Each dish came piping hot and ready, confirming that quality and efficiency go hand in hand.
- Blackened Salmon Sub: A standout dish made with expertly seasoned salmon, praised by Hunter Hastings during his rainy weekday visit.
- Handmade Sandwiches: Each creation, crafted with care, showcases the owners' commitment to excellence, as highlighted by Joseph Duggan.
Costello's Market truly embodies the spirit of community and culinary excellence. The hands-on involvement of the owners, combined with their passion for food, ensures that every visit is memorable. In a world filled with chains and fast-food options, Costello's stands out as a beacon for those in search of authenticity and connection.
So whether you're after a quick sandwich, a hearty meal, or simply a chat with some friendly faces, Costello's Market is waiting to welcome you with open arms and tantalizing flavors. Don’t miss out on exploring this delightful food haven in the heart of Middlebury!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place is an amazing hidden gem! The fresh fish, salads, and many other goodies are top tier I sadly should have gotten a larger size of the broccoli salad because oh my goodness!!! Even better, the owner is so kind and enjoyable to interact with! Definitely give them a try if you haven't already! ... ”
“ Had a shrimp po boy for a late lunch today. It was absolutely phenomenal! The shrimp was warm, lightly breaded and cooked to perfection, the baguette was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, and the veggies and dressing were fresh and yummy! Fantastic!! ”
“ Incredible meal and friendly staff. We ordered sandwiches for a family of 5 and everything came out hot and ready in about 15 minutes. We got the fish and chips, baby Bella and roasted pepper sandwich, Pate on baguette, and pulled pork. Sorry that I didn’t take pictures because everything looked and tasted incredible. We will definitely be going back! ”
“ went in on a rainy weekday for a quick lunch sandwich. Overwhelmed with all of the options, in a good way. Ended up getting a fantastic blackened salmon sub. The owner is wicked talkative and nice. Food is amazing. ”
“ This is a total gem of a deli and specialty store. The sandwiches and other handmade food is excellent. The owners are very friendly and totally hands on in everything they do. Any neighborhood would be very lucky to have a Costello's so Middlebury, Vermont is privileged like no other. ”
“ I ordered the large Roma (capicola, provolone) sandwich, and it was one of the best sandwiches I've ever eaten. Barely more expensive than a place like subway. Eat at this place!! ”
“ Best sandwich in town! My favorite is the Classic, but you can't go wrong with any of their food. Also, the chili they have in the winter months is the best! ”
“ My coworker got me addicted to their Soprano sandwich. Fresh bread and meat. Can’t wait to try more of their menu! Friendly staff always. ”